How to write selection criteria with STAR (with an example)
Selection criteria are the skills and qualities a government or not-for-profit employer has decided the job needs. You're asked to show, with evidence, that you meet each one. Done well, they're the most persuasive part of your application. Done badly, they're why good people don't get interviews.
Read the criterion closely
Take "Demonstrated ability to deliver high-quality client service in a complex environment". It has three parts: demonstrated (a real example, not a claim), high-quality client service (what you did for people) and complex environment (why it was hard). Your answer needs all three.
Use STAR
- Situation: where you were and what was going on. One or two sentences.
- Task: what you had to achieve.
- Action: what you did, step by step. This is the longest part.
- Result: what changed, with a number if you have one, and what you learned.
Most responses run 250 to 400 words per criterion unless the ad sets a limit. Write in the first person and in plain English. Don't use the STAR labels as headings: write flowing paragraphs in that order.
A worked example
In 2024 our team took on enquiries about a new payment while the guidance was still being finalised, and wait times grew to over 40 minutes. As a senior officer, my task was to help callers get accurate answers first time and reduce repeat calls.
I built a one-page call guide from the policy updates, checked it with our policy team, and shared it at the morning briefing. I also set up a shared log of tricky questions so answers were consistent across shifts, and I took escalated calls myself when the queue peaked.
Over the next six weeks our team's repeat-call rate fell from 22% to 14%, and the guide was adopted by two other teams.
Notice what it does: a specific situation, a clear task, actions that are the writer's own, and a result with numbers.
Map it to the framework
APS ads often refer to the Integrated Leadership System (ILS) for the level, and NSW ads to the NSW Public Sector Capability Framework. Read the behaviours for your level and use their words where they're true: "builds productive working relationships", "communicates with influence".
Pitches instead of criteria
Many APS jobs now ask for a one-page pitch (500 to 1,000 words) instead of separate criteria. The same rules apply: two or three strong examples, mapped to the key duties, with results.
Common mistakes
- Restating the criterion instead of giving an example.
- "We" all the way through: the panel needs to know what you did.
- No result, or a result with no evidence.
- Reusing one example for every criterion.
In the Cvazo builder, the Selection Criteria step takes your notes for each criterion and drafts a STAR response in your words, with a live word count, and the APS pitch writer does the same for a one-page pitch.
More
How long should a resume be in Australia?
Two to three pages for most experienced roles, one page for a first job. Here's how to decide, and what to cut.
How to tailor your resume to a Seek job ad in 10 minutes
A fast, honest way to match your resume to each ad: find the keywords, prove them, and fix the top of the page.
Max Demunck, Founder, Cvazo
Max built Cvazo so Australian job seekers can make a resume that fits Australian applications, and download it free.